Admittedly this is the first book of Ackerman's that I struggled with. It's not that it wasn't a good book it's more that it just took it's time getting there if that makes sense. It started out really strong, the first couple of chapters were well written and set readers up for an engrossing tale. But then somewhere around the 20% mark it started to lose steam for me. I had a hard time believing that Isabel wanted to go to Hawaii to basically retrace the footsteps of her deceased brother. On the surface it made sense but as we got into the story where she meets Mateo and retracing her brother's favorite spots as a catalyst for their romance just felt weird and off to me. For me it just didn't work and felt a little off. The first half of the book mostly covered Mateo and Isabel going to her brother's favorite spots and Mateo documenting those spots and the whole time I was thinking "Why???? What's the point of this???". And Mateo's devotion to all those spots and memories felt a little weird too. Can't explain it but it just didn't feel fitting some how. I struggled with Lu's parts of the book too. There seemed to be zero connection between Lu and Mateo later on in the book and I just really struggled to get into that part of the story. For some reason this whole book felt very mismatched and strung together but not in a good way. After the 50% mark things eventually picked up and got better (no spoilers!) but by that point I was already feeling disconnected and bored with some of the story. It took too long getting there and getting to the interesting parts for my taste. This was unexpected for me because Ackerman's books have generally been really good. This book started out with her trademark love of Hawaii and it's war time history. I loved that part and I loved the descriptions of the island and it's rugged beauty. But the characters felt lacking for me. While this book didn't excite me as some of Ackerman's other novels, I think it's still worth a read. It's not bad but for me, I felt like her other novels were stronger and I think this one could have been better than it was. Ackerman is still an author that I recommend a lot to readers looking for 'off the beaten path' WWII novels. She is a marvelous writer and I love how she writes and the stories she tells, but in this one I think it could have been better. Admittedly this is the first book of Ackerman's that I struggled with. It's not that it wasn't a good book it's more that it just took it's time getting there if that makes sense. It started out really strong, the first couple of chapters were well written and set readers up for an engrossing tale. But then somewhere around the 20% mark it started to lose steam for me. I had a hard time believing that Isabel wanted to go to Hawaii to basically retrace the footsteps of her deceased brother. On the surface it made sense but as we got into the story where she meets Mateo and retracing her brother's favorite spots as a catalyst for their romance just felt weird and off to me. For me it just didn't work and felt a little off. The first half of the book mostly covered Mateo and Isabel going to her brother's favorite spots and Mateo documenting those spots and the whole time I was thinking "Why???? What's the point of this???". And Mateo's devotion to all those spots and memories felt a little weird too. Can't explain it but it just didn't feel fitting some how. I struggled with Lu's parts of the book too. There seemed to be zero connection between Lu and Mateo later on in the book and I just really struggled to get into that part of the story. For some reason this whole book felt very mismatched and strung together but not in a good way. After the 50% mark things eventually picked up and got better (no spoilers!) but by that point I was already feeling disconnected and bored with some of the story. It took too long getting there and getting to the interesting parts for my taste. This was unexpected for me because Ackerman's books have generally been really good. This book started out with her trademark love of Hawaii and it's war time history. I loved that part and I loved the descriptions of the island and it's rugged beauty. But the characters felt lacking for me. While this book didn't excite me as some of Ackerman's other novels, I think it's still worth a read. It's not bad but for me, I felt like her other novels were stronger and I think this one could have been better than it was. Ackerman is still an author that I recommend a lot to readers looking for 'off the beaten path' WWII novels. She is a marvelous writer and I love how she writes and the stories she tells, but in this one I think it could have been better.

Veteran writer Richman partners with debut author Edwards in a Civil War--era novel about the converging paths of two families. In New Orleans, Stella, a Black woman, says goodbye to her beloved, William, as he leaves to join the Union army. In New York City, Lily, a Jewish woman, contributes to the abolitionist movement and pens letters to her husband, Jacob, a Union army musician. While serving, William and Jacob form a friendship over music, and the lives of all four are then drawn together. The Thread Collectors pushes back against simple Civil War narratives and spotlights historical realities, including the abysmal treatment of Black Union soldiers, Southern antisemitism, and Northern racism. While William and Jacob fight these injustices on the ground, Stella and Lily cleverly use thread as their own means of fighting back with quiet but powerful courage. This book, with its distinct prose, quick chapters, and dynamic characters, provides a stirring narrative and much-needed perspective in Civil War fiction.

This collaboration by longtime friends Edwards and Richman draws on the authors' Black and Jewish family histories to build an expressly uplifting Civil War fiction. The novel begins in 1863 New Orleans, showcasing the forbidden but abiding love between musically gifted William, a classically trained flutist who's enslaved, and Stella, who lives technically free as the kept woman of William's current owner. With Stella's aid, William escapes to join the Union Army as a member of the Louisiana Native Guard. Meanwhile, in New York, trombonist and composer Jacob has been inspired by his wife, Lily, a suffragette and abolitionist, to join the Union forces on moral grounds. The novel balances three intertwining narratives: Pregnant with a child who could be William's or his master's, Stella struggles to survive in Union-controlled New Orleans, where food is scarce and Confederate insurrection a constant threat; William and Jacob experience wartime atrocities while their unlikely friendship deepens through their music connection; and in New York, Lily devotes herself to the Union cause with genteel moral certainty until she ventures South in search of Jacob and faces her naïveté about the war's cost. Given that African Americans in the South had everything to gain or lose in this war, it is no surprise that Stella's and William's segments are the most compelling; the writing about New Orleans also creates a sensual, specific sense of place missing elsewhere. Lily reads like a mouthpiece for enlightened concepts, even in her love letters. There is no romantic chemistry between her and Jacob, who remains an undeveloped cipher. What should be an interesting twist, his discomfort as a Jewish outsider in the Union ranks, barely resonates, while his bonding with William comes too easily. All four protagonists are more noble symbols than characters, and key plot points--including Stella's stitched maps and Jacob's estrangement from his Confederate brother--border on Civil War story clichés. Well-intentioned but overly familiar. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.